Ishwa helper Reged: 03/03/02 Posts: 553

Re: Ishwa: Plz respond to Arya tribal invasion theory [Re: Americanhindu] #29134 - 04/24/03 07:31 AM Edit Reply Quote

What are you actually up to, AmH. I don't understand a bit of your discussing technique. Fragmentary comments and fragmentary quotes pasted from another subject elsewhere doesn't lead to a clear understanding. For me it is puzzling as to what exactly I have to reply. Please try to be a little bit more cooperative in a dialogue mode, and not use fragmentarized quotes for your monologue-like sounding replies I'm sorry for repeating it again and again: I really don't understand your style and what you actually want me to reply to you. Being more specific and quoting more accurately, without interpreting before I have even answered, would certainly help. I sincerely believe that you don't really read or understand what I have posted previously. I have a sense that you do confuse me with someone. I am NOT an adherer of the AIT. let's look at two of your remarks: In reply to: ARYA Tribe had values that were considered to be extremely NOBLE. They obsessively practiced what they preached in their scriptures or given in their scriptures as guidelines for living a vedic cultured life. Only the word "obsessively" is enough indication that you really have no notion of what Vedic Culture is. The word 'noble' and 'obsessively' are contradictory terms for the Vedic Culture. In reply to: There is no way, those so called invaders demonstrated anything "noble" by thier invasive, intrusive actions at all. What do you want to say with this remark? 1. There was no invasion, because you use the word 'so-called'. This would mean that you don't believe in an invasion or that you assume that I believe in such, as you are replying to some (ghost) post of mine. 2. Then the word 'noble' is again put against 'invasive, intrusive actions'. If you don't assume an invasion, why opening the door a little and question that an 'invasive intrusion' was not in accordance with a 'noble' action? I am not confused, perhaps you aren't either. But the way you put things together in your replies, perhaps unintentionally, certainly are confusing and not really forming one logical composed mass. So, again, if you want fruitful DIAlogues, which means that there are dia=two peoples involved in a discussion, than you really need to be accurate in quoting, asking questions and putting your own thoughts down, in order to facilitate the process and progress. regards, Ishwa